The Doc wrote:xl_target wrote: As with any mechanical device, if you use it incorrectly, the chances of failure are greatly increased.
Right, the chances of failure are
greater with a semi-auto pistol as compared to a revolver, it seems.
best,
Rp.
Yes, the more mechanical parts in a device, the greater the chance of failure. However, when a well engineered device, like today's semi automatic firearms, is used properly (as designed to be used) the rate of failure is close to zero. When I first started shooting handguns, I suffered the same limitations; stovepipes and double feeds. Once I was made aware of the importance of proper grip and other techniques, I didn't have any more problems. For example, My CZ P-06 has never had a single failure to feed, failure to fire or a failure to eject and this is after thousands of rounds through the gun. I bought that particular handgun after I had been shooting for a while.
I will definitely grant you your point that if as a newby to handguns, I had started with a revolver, I would never have had any of those problems. However, it was my limitations, my lack of knowledge and my inability to use the semi-auto as it was designed to be used, that caused the problem. There are very few reasons for a semi-auto, when properly used, to fail. The reason that, I personally, would chose a semi auto over a revolver would be the number of rounds available in the gun and the ability to recharge the gun quickly. For example, in a recent IDPA styled match, I was able to shoot 9 targets (double tapping each one, as required) in 37 seconds (yeah, I know, slower than molasses) while on the move between stations. This included three magazine changes as the mag in my SIG only holds eight rounds. The only reason I bring this up is to show that if I had a revolver, it would have taken me significantly longer, even with speed loaders. None of my semi auto handguns have any feed, fire or ejection failures any more when I am running them.
I will also bring up the fact that i had to be taught to drive a vehicle. I didn't just get in the car and take off without any instruction. if i had, I probably wouldn't have been around to type this right now. I was not taught to ride a bicycle when I was a kid. I learned how to by myself .......after many cuts, bruises and some damage to the bicycle.
“Never give in, never give in, never; never; never; never – in nothing, great or small, large or petty – never give in except to convictions of honor and good sense” — Winston Churchill, Oct 29, 1941